
This guide on the best trading cards to collect was a little more complex than we first suspected. The best doesn’t simply mean the most expensive, and we’ve had to do some serious digging to piece this one together. You’ll learn more about our methodology, including the elements that we consider before ranking the best trading cards. Then, we provide you with a snapshot of those that made the cut across a range of popular franchises and sports. To finish, we guide you through what it means to be a collector, including ripping, grading, protecting, and enjoying the hobby.
Before we take a closer look at what we consider the best trading cards to collect across the most popular CCGs and sports, we want to ensure you understand how we judged them. As you’ll see, market value does play its role, but it isn’t the only thing to consider.
| Verified auction sales | The price will play its part. However, there are plenty of inflated prices around, and we will only take verified auction sales into account |
| Estimated market price | We like to see the latest movement of trading cards. Those on a primarily upward trend or those that have been consistently high-risers will get our vote |
| Historical or cultural significance | Cards like the Mickey Mantle #311 are considered to have changed the game for sports collectors. We look at cards that have either significantly altered things for the hobby, sport, or any other reason |
| Print runs, graded population, and overall scarcity | How easy it is to get hold of a trading card will influence our decision as well. If hundreds and thousands of copies are available, graded population is high, and print runs continue, the price is unlikely to reach huge peaks |
| Artwork and card design | There is much to be said about the artists working behind the scenes, and the overall design of the card. Tri-panel sports cards can pick up three GOATs in one card, and top artists can really bring Pokémon and One Piece to life |
| Athletes and characters | It is the athletes and characters that will make or break a specific card. Popularity and fan base is a huge part of things, and you’ll find that some big names feature in our latest list |
| Era and sets | The most popular eras in sports, card collecting, and anime will always receive a small boost. Whether looking at NBA cards from the 80s, new full-art grails from Pokémon, or something a little different |
Now for the fun bit. Here, we have an updated look at the very best cards across four of the most popular collectible categories today: Pokémon, One Piece, baseball, and football.
Pokémon is arguably the most popular collectible card game today. Some of the best Pokémon trading cards to buy are now worth millions of dollars, and the product continues to fly off the shelves. However, it hasn’t always been this way. Back in the day, you could easily buy your packs for a few dollars, find fan favorites like Charizard and Pikachu, and soon add them to your binder or send them off for grading. Now, with popularity continuing to soar, you’ll find you need to enter a virtual queue or wait outside the store for new drops. Artwork continues to impress, and new modern-day grails, like the Umbreon VMax, compete with vintage greats and exclusive promos, as you can see from this table.
| Rank | Card | Set | Estimated Value | Reason for selection |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Charizard 004 | Base Set Shadowless | $462, 500 (PSA 10) | Pure nostalgia |
| 2 | Pokémon Illustrator | Promo | $16 million (PSA 10) | Only one PSA 10 confirmed |
| 3 | Umbreon VMax | Evolving Skies | $4,025 (PSA 10) | The modern-day grail |
One Piece is arguably the second most popular anime CCG, and it is easy to see why. They have found a great balance between playability, affordability, and beautiful artwork, making it an inclusive option for those looking to build their collections. Price has risen over the last two years, and you’ll find that fewer print runs are completed compared with other collectible card franchises. This makes those top-end cards real hidden gems and collector’s pieces to be admired. Our rankings see Monkey.D.Luffy secure the top spot from the Awakening of The New Era. This set celebrates the first anniversary of One Piece, and the Gear 5 Luffy is the crown jewel. This is closely followed by the original grail of Shanks (OP01-120), and a fan favorite in Portgas.D.Ace (OP02-13)
| Rank | Card | Set | Estimated Value | Reason for selection |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Monkey.D.Luffy (OP05-119 Manga Rare) | Awakening of the New Era | $8,400 (PSA 10) | First year anniversary |
| 2 | Shanks (OP01-120 Manga Rare) | Romance Dawn | $6,100 (PSA 10) | Set the standard |
| 3 | Portgas.D.Ace (OP02-13 Manga Rare) | Paramount War | $2,935 (PSA 10) | Recent rise in value |
You can go all the way back to 1868 to find baseball cards, but things have certainly moved on since then. Prior to the rise of Topps, you would have some of the best baseball trading cards in cigarette packs and chewing gum. The first real card collecting boom for baseball fans came between the ‘30s and ‘50s, and it was that Mickey Mantle #311 card that really changed the pace of things. In fact, that card didn’t just change the game for baseball collecting; it changed it for sports card collectors across the board. Unsurprisingly, the Mickey Mantle remains one of the most expensive sports cards around, with a PSA 10 sale taking its value over $11 million. This is closely followed by the fantastic Jackie Robinson #30 and the record-breaking Hank Aaron #128 Rookie.
| Rank | Card | Set | Estimated Value | Reason for selection |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mickey Mantle #331 | 1952 Topps | $11,418,819 (PSA 10) | The most significant card in sports trading history |
| 2 | Jackie Robinson #30 | 1956 Topps | $128,100 (PSA 9) | Incredible backstory |
| 3 | Hank Aaron #128 Rookie | 1954 Topps | $357,594 (PSA 10) | Record breaker |
Like baseball cards, you can trace some of the best football trading cards back to the late 1800’s, where tobacco and gum packets featured one or two fan favorites. The first-ever card was an insert featuring Yale’s Henry Beecher. Since then, the National Chicle release in 1935 was the first comprehensive set, and the post-war revival saw Bowman and Topps release cards in candy packs in association with the NFL. Fast-forward to 1960 and beyond, and you’ll find glossy finishes, team details, and full-color photography, which is where you will find our top picks, including the rookie cards of some of the greats.
| Rank | Card | Set | Estimated Value | Reason for selection |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Barry Sanders #257 Rookie | 1989 Score | $2,175 | Legendary HOF running back |
| 2 | Jerry Rice #61 Rookie | 1986 Topps | $84,000 | Considered the one and only rookie card for Rice |
| 3 | Dan Marino #123 Rookie | 1984 Topps | $5,898 | Post 5,000+ yard and 48 TD season |
Although these may be what we consider to be top-rated options, your own opinions on the best sports trading cards and non-sports grails may differ – and that is absolutely fine. In fact, we would suggest that it should do, at least a little. We say this not to discredit our rankings, but because collecting cards should be a personal thing. Those in our list have been hand-selected by our experts based on various factors, as discussed earlier, but you will undoubtedly favor certain elements over others when searching for cards yourself. So, what should you be looking out for?
First and foremost, you need to focus on what you enjoy – Pokémon, One Piece, baseball, football, Lorcana, whatever it may be. Then, you need to focus on the type of collector. Of course, you can change your mind throughout, but it is wise to have an idea of how you want to kick your collection off.
Depending on your preferences, it isn’t quite as easy as placing an order online or heading down to your local store. In some instances, you can absolutely do this, but popular collectibles, like Lorcana and Pokémon, fly off the shelves quicker than you’d imagine. A couple of options would be to head on down to a card show or find yourself a local vendor; here you can barter and trade your own cards against your own grails, or even find fresh packs to rip. Alternatively, you will find card rip sites are becoming popular, allowing you to buy packs with the potential to unlock gems through digital streams. These cards can then either be sold, stored as an NFT (at some sites), or shipped out to you.
When you get hold of your next rips, you’ll want to make sure that you look after them. The easiest way to help maintain the condition of your cards is by putting them straight into penny sleeves and a binder. If you end up ripping some top-end cards, we would suggest placing those in a penny sleeve and then into a toploader. If you receive graded cards, then you’ll already find that they are preserved in cases from official grading companies; however, you can still protect these further by getting the correct case and a protective sleeve.
As briefly mentioned, grading will encase your cards and preserve them in the same condition for a lifetime. However, did you know that these grades can also improve the overall value of your cards? Generally speaking, grades of PSA 8 and above will increase the value of modern cards across most genres, but this differs considerably for those cards that fall into the vintage category. We would suggest purchasing a tool or interacting with vendors to see if it could be worth sending off some of your latest pulls for grading.
With your binders in check, it now pays to download an app or sign yourself up to a site that allows you to track your collection. For master sets, you’ll often find paper copies are available, but if you are making up your own collection, then it makes sense to grab the app or input your details onto a dedicated tracking site to see how things are going. You should be able to input cards, view current price, and even see price history. Although value isn’t the main thing for all of us, it is nice to watch things grow.
The best trading cards to collect will vary greatly based on your preferences, and it shouldn’t solely be about value. Of course, it is nice to know your investment has some potential for returns, but you should focus more on having fun and building a collection that means something to you. Whether you want to collect every single Cubone, all cards from Topps 1952, or graded slabs of the NFL’s finest, you’re in the right place with us here at The Spike. We have countless reviews of card rip sites, guides focused on grading, articles highlighting the most-valuable cards, and so much more for you to enjoy.
There is no single answer that we can give here. The reality is that collecting is personal to you. We find that most will look to collect full master sets, specific players or characters, top-end chases, or only slabs. However, you can collect whatever cards mean the most to you.
The best way to get the most out of the trading cards that you have collected is by looking after them, showing them off, and trading with friends. We also suggest tracking the value with a reliable app or site to follow your own progress.
You can find top-end trading cards to collect at local card shows, through online marketplaces, and by ripping packs. Recently, we have also seen the launch of card rip sites, where you can rip packs online and sell (buyback) them or have items shipped out to you.